Trump’s Birthright Citizenship Order Draws Lines Scholars Find Indefensible
Different treatment for mothers and fathers is at odds with a 2017 Supreme Court decision, and other ideas in the order are hard to understand.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor questioned on Wednesday whether a ruling in favor of the Trump administration’s executive order on birthright citizenship would retroactively strip citizenship from people born on U.S. soil to illegal immigrant or tourist parents. The justices heard arguments in Trump v. Barbara, a challenge to Trump’s 2025 executive order that…
Different treatment for mothers and fathers is at odds with a 2017 Supreme Court decision, and other ideas in the order are hard to understand.
For 128 years, it’s been clear that if you are born in this country, you are a citizen. The court must not turn back the clockI am lead counsel in the challenge to Donald Trump’s birthright citizenship executive order. As I and my team help the ACLU legal director, Cecillia Wang, prepare for the supreme court argument in this case on Wednesday, we are…
The Supreme Court heard arguments Wednesday on a challenge to President Donald Trump's executive order banning most birthright citizenship, with the president making an unprecedented appearance to witness the debate. Justices expressed skepticism on the lawfulness of his proposal to limit the constitutional guarantee of birthright citizenship for people…
The Supreme Court on Wednesday morning weighed President Trump’s bid for restrictions on birthright citizenship, with the president in the room. The face-to-face moment made Trump the first known sitting president to attend an oral argument. Also, with the public’s impatience surrounding the high court’s rulings, what does a typical Supreme Court timeline…
The Supreme Court struggled Wednesday with how to treat President Trump's attempt to block children of illegal immigrants and short-term visitors from getting birthright U.S. citizenship, with the justices trying to stack his executive order up against more than a century of tradition.
The Supreme Court heard oral arguments on Wednesday in the case challenging President Donald Trump's executive order to end birthright citizenship.Trump made history by being the first sitting president to attend a SCOTUS hearing. He attended for over an hour, departing shortly after the solicitor general, John Sauer, concluded his arguments.'Why put it in…
Understanding the Supreme Court’s oral arguments in Trump v. Barbara.