The supreme court’s voting rights decision is a death knell for American democracy | Moira Donegan

Source: US news | The Guardian · Bias: Center Left

Summary

The US was not a true democracy before the Voting Rights Act. Wednesday’s decision has essentially destroyed the lawIs America a democracy? The term implies an equality of rights and dignity among citizens, a collective and uniform right of individuals to participate in self-government and to shape the laws that rule them. In that sense, the answer is no: though it has been a republic since its founding, America has only rarely been a true democracy, one where all citizens have the full right to vote and to have that vote counted.Political scientists such as the University of Notre Dame’s Christine Wolbrecht have argued that America wasn’t really a democracy, not in the meaningful sense of the term, until the passage of the Voting Rights Act, the law that formed the signature achievement of the civil rights movement and sought to end racial barriers to voting across the south when it was passed in 1965. If you accept that premise, you could say that the era of American democracy officially ended on Wednesday, when the supreme court finished its project of dismantling the VRA in its 6-3 decision in Louisiana v Callais. Whatever this country has become now, “democracy” does not describe it.Moira Donegan is a Guardian US columnist Continue reading...

Related Coverage

Daily Analysis

Read the full Parallax Pulse for April 29, 2026 — an AI-powered analysis of how Left and Right media covered the biggest stories this day.

More Headlines From April 29, 2026

arallaxNews.io
The supreme court’s voting rights decision is a death knell for American democracy | Moira Donegan
US news | The Guardian

The supreme court’s voting rights decision is a death knell for American democracy | Moira Donegan

Center Left

The US was not a true democracy before the Voting Rights Act. Wednesday’s decision has essentially destroyed the lawIs America a democracy? The term implies an equality of rights and dignity among citizens, a collective and uniform right of individuals to participate in self-government and to shape the laws that rule them. In that sense, the answer is no: though it has been a republic since its founding, America has only rarely been a true democracy, one where all citizens have the full right to vote and to have that vote counted.Political scientists such as the University of Notre Dame’s Christine Wolbrecht have argued that America wasn’t really a democracy, not in the meaningful sense of the term, until the passage of the Voting Rights Act, the law that formed the signature achievement of the civil rights movement and sought to end racial barriers to voting across the south when it was passed in 1965. If you accept that premise, you could say that the era of American democracy officially ended on Wednesday, when the supreme court finished its project of dismantling the VRA in its 6-3 decision in Louisiana v Callais. Whatever this country has become now, “democracy” does not describe it.Moira Donegan is a Guardian US columnist Continue reading...

Read Full Story at Source
The supreme court’s voting rights decision is a death knell for American democracy | Moira Donegan | ParallaxNews.io