John Roberts' public 'chastizing' of right-wing justice flagged by legal expert
Source: Raw Story · Bias: Far Left
Summary
A legal scholar on Friday zeroed in on Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s dissent in the Supreme Court’s sweeping tariff ruling, saying it stood out not just for its shaky legal footing but for how closely it mirrored the government’s arguments.In an interview on CNN, NYU law professor Ryan Goodman said he was struck by Kavanaugh’s role in the three-justice dissent – and by how the majority responded to it.“It's a bit of a surprise to see him in this three-member dissent because they're basically wrong on the law and the supermajority of federal judges have said so,” Goodman said. He pointed to what he called an "unusual" addition to the majority opinion authored by Chief Justice John Roberts, where Roberts openly criticized the dissent.“Chief Justice Roberts does something quite unusual,” Goodman said. “He actually chastises Kavanaugh a bit by saying that the government's argument was echoed point by point by the principal dissent.”When Roberts made that observation, Goodman explained, “he's basically saying Chief Justice Roberts is saying that Kavanaugh was parroting the government's position.”But Goodman suggested that Kavanaugh siding with the MAGA administration’s position in the tariff ruling may be a way of setting himself up to strike down future challenges to the Supreme Court.“The fact that he parrots it, the fact that he's in the dissent, I think, gives him more room to maneuver back into the majority when other cases are coming up before the court, in which I do think he might very well invalidate some of the actions,” Goodman said about the Trump-appointed justice. "I think he's bought himself and the court more legitimacy and more room to do so," he added.
Related Coverage
- 'You're screaming in front of children!' Right-wing activist all he can handle in Philly (Far Left — Raw Story)
- Mt. Olive Pickle Co. exits Great American State Fair over Confederate flag (Center — The Hill News)
- Karoline Leavitt warns ‘full-blown Communist revolution’ taking place right NOW (Far Right — BizPac Review)
- Justice Department defends decision not to release, unredact more Epstein files (Center — NewsNation)
- Justice Department defends decision not to release, unredact more Epstein files (Center — The Hill News)
- Senator John Fetterman Reveals the One Thing That Would Make Him Leave the Democrat Party (VIDEO) (Far Right — The Gateway Pundit)
- SCOTUS Birthplace Citizenship Decision Is John Roberts’ Roe v. Wade (Far Right — The Federalist)
- How did 16 hidden Ohio kids go undetected for years? Experts weigh in (Center — NewsNation)
More Headlines From February 21, 2026
- Trump escalates tariffs despite Supreme Court loss (Left)
- Supreme Court conservatives split sides with liberals in Trump tariffs ruling (Center Right)
- Inside the hidden factor fueling Trump's anger at the Supreme Court (Left)
- WSJ demands 'ugly' Trump apologize to the Supreme Court (Left)
- Trump chastised for plan to introduce 'more chaos' (Left)








