John Roberts' landmark 2019 decision just backfired spectacularly on GOP: legal analysts
Source: Raw Story · Bias: Far Left
Summary
Chief Justice John Roberts paved the way for a major Democratic victory this week with a decision he made at the end of the last decade, political analysts are pointing out. Justice Roberts delivered a key decision in the 2019 case Rucho v. Common Cause. Roberts siding with conservatives on a 5-4 decision seven years ago kept constitutional limits away from partisan gerrymandering. Dahlia Lithwick and Mark Joseph Stern, co-hosts of the Slate legal analysis podcast Amicus, revisited Roberts' decision in their latest episode and explained how the case gave way to a major Democratic victory in Virginia this week, where voters approved a gerrymandered map that opens four House seats. "There was a lot of Republican bellyaching this week over these results," Lithwick said. "But didn’t the Supreme Court pretty much roll out the red carpet for this kind of electoral hardball with the decision in Rucho v. Common Cause?"Stern suggested that Roberts "thought this would disproportionately help Republicans over Democrats," but "I doubt he expected states like Virginia to play hardball. But this is exactly what Roberts said he wanted: Let the states decide!"Madiba Dennie, the deputy editor of Balls and Strikes who appeared on the Amicus episode, called the irony "funny because Republicans could have come together with Democrats at any time and said, 'we're going to end partisan gerrymandering.'"Instead, Republicans said "we want to rig ourselves a structural advantage," Dennie said. "And now that Democratic voters decided they want a little structural advantage too, Republicans scream and cry."
Related Coverage
- Penn Dems boot GOP Rep from House floor for patriotic suit despite encouraging ‘Pride’ attire (Far Right — BizPac Review)
- Pay-to-play cycle behind GOP's corporate tax cuts exposed in new report (Far Left — Raw Story)
- Mamdani mocked by GOP for telling New Yorkers to set thermostats to 78 (Center — The Hill News)
- Justice Department defends decision not to release, unredact more Epstein files (Center — NewsNation)
- Justice Department defends decision not to release, unredact more Epstein files (Center — The Hill News)
- Senator John Fetterman Reveals the One Thing That Would Make Him Leave the Democrat Party (VIDEO) (Far Right — The Gateway Pundit)
- Republicans circle wagons around indicted GOP AG: report (Left — Alternet.org)
- SCOTUS Birthplace Citizenship Decision Is John Roberts’ Roe v. Wade (Far Right — The Federalist)
Daily Analysis
Read the full Parallax Pulse for April 25, 2026 — an AI-powered analysis of how Left and Right media covered the biggest stories this day.
More Headlines From April 25, 2026
- Trump admin just handed ballroom firm another secret $17 million no-bid contract (Left)
- ‘Nobody knows what’s going on’: Bolton on US-Iran talks (Center)
- President Trump Attends the White House Correspondents Dinner – Livestream Links (Far Right)
- BREAKING: President Trump Rushed Out of White House Correspondents’ Dinner After Shots Fired – SHOOTER DOWN (VIDEO) (Far Right)
- Trump Cancels US Envoys’ Trip to Pakistan for Iran Talks (Center)








